In his recent blog post, Richard Holt explored whether Covid-19 will lead to a permanent flight from the cities as people and their employers make permanent their favourable pandemic experiences—thus taking a job once located in a major city to a quieter area with lower housing costs and a more relaxed lifestyle. While he could imagine that people in their 30s and 40s will move out of large cities like London to an even greater degree than before (and advertises Bordeaux!), Richard does not expect the pandemic to lead to a major reorganization of work and living patterns, as the pull of big city life will remain.
In most emerging market (EM) economies, it is even less likely for people to leave urban areas on a large scale, as the quality of life tends to be so much better there than in the rural areas where they come from. Take China, where hundreds of millions of people have migrated to cities in recent decades, drawn by higher incomes and better infrastructure and public services such as health and education. While infrastructure and services in the countryside have improved over time, the gap with cities remains vast. Indeed, since the outbreak of Covid-19 in February 2020, the number of people that have moved out of the large cities has remained small.
Of course in several ways China is not representative of what is happening in EMs. For one, in various EMs, the economic damage caused by the pandemic and government lockdowns has been significantly larger than in either advanced countries or China. India is a case in point: many millions of people tried to return home to their place of origin when the government imposed a lockdown of urban economies in end-March 2020, and many of them have not returned to the cities—yet. But as the Indian post-pandemic recovery matures, most of those people will likely be keen to return to metropolitan areas, if they have the choice.
It is hard to generalize. Significant numbers of Indian white-collar workers enjoy remote working and some may end up living outside the largest cities because of their experience during Covid-19, similar to their British peers. But, generally speaking, in most EMs the charm of living in the countryside, or even in smaller cities, is less convincing than in advanced economies, making it less likely that large numbers of people will be keen to leave the big cities permanently.
You may be interested in
Morocco: The economic impact of the Al-Haouz earthquake
The human cost of the earthquake that struck Morocco on September 8 has been terrible, but lower than it could have been. The same is true of the economic cost. We have taken a closer look at the economies of the affected regions, and at government's emergency response plan, to evaluate the economic impact.Find Out More
Beyond the headlines: UK fiscal rules
Fiscal rules should aim to ensure fiscal sustainability and inter-generational fairness while helping to promote longer term societal goals such as higher potential growth and the transition to net zero. In this week’s Beyond the Headlines, join Michael Saunders, Senior Economic Advisor, as he examines the UK’s three fiscal rules.Find Out More
Beyond the headlines: Will global economic resilience last?
The world economy performed better in the final months of 2022 and early 2023 than might have been expected, given the scale of the inflation and interest rate shocks it suffered. In this week’s Beyond the Headlines, join Adam Slater, Lead Economist, as he discusses global economic resilience and whether it will last.Find Out More