Research Briefing | Aug 31, 2023

How to improve the fiscal rules

Reforms to the UK’s fiscal framework would help put the public finances on a more sustainable path and provide a better platform for a much-needed strategy to improve the economy’s supply side, in our view.

Specifically, we think the UK should have three fiscal rules: to improve public sector net worth over a five-10-year horizon; to aim for a cyclically adjusted current balance each year; and to cut public debt on a three-year horizon.

To reduce undesirable feedback from monetary policy to fiscal policy, the debt target should exclude the effects of transfers from the Bank of England’s asset purchase facility. There should also be an escape clause to allow more time to achieve the deficit and debt targets if monetary policy is seriously constrained by the effective lower bound.

In addition, the OBR should extend its forecast horizon to 10 years to allow a better assessment of the longer-term impact of supply-side policies, including public investment, and introduce a formal ‘yellow card’ scheme to highlight persistent slippage from the fiscal plans.

Changes along these lines would not remove the need to implement further fiscal tightening to prevent public debts from trending higher. But they would help ensure medium-term fiscal sustainability, while allowing more scope to lift public investment as part of a comprehensive strategy to lift the UK’s potential growth.

Back to Resource Hub

Related posts


A murky way forward for French politics

The second round of the French snap elections resulted in a hung parliament, as we expected. Even though the Nouveau Front Populaire (NFP), an alliance of left-wing parties recorded a surprisingly strong performance and finished in first place, we think France is still set for policy paralysis, as an Assembly split in 3 large blocs will be unable to underpin a stable government.

Find Out More
Eurozone: When forward guidance blurs guidance


Eurozone: The fiscal consolidation conundrum for governments
Find Out More


US Recession Monitor – Economy recovering from Q1 stumble

The economy slowed following the strong gains in the second half of last year, as it settled into a more sustainable growth pace. However, our business cycle indicator shows that growth improved midway through the second quarter and corroborates our expectations for Q2 GDP to rise about 2% at an annualized rate.

Find Out More